>I have initially suggested the video because of the successful description
>of the learning process that the father (Nick Nolte in the movie) has gone
>through. For me the value of the movie is in the self driven process of
>enquiry and not in the way the initial decison to fight against the
>illness has been taken.
=====================================================================
I do agree with this point, it does suggest a process of re-evaluation of
a process. Let me propose, for discussion the day to day problem I argue
against. I see the need for evaluating processes, even those which are
working. I do not agree with Mr. Tom Peters, if it ain't broken, break
it. However, the day to day balance problem is the Nick Nolte type which,
as you put it is, Self Driven, and challenges the processes to an extreme.
I think it is healthy for experimentation, but uncontrolled
experimentation by the Self Driven is a constant problem for me.
This past week, in my organization, I turned down a Senior VP position
because this issue bothers me. Systems are in place on which I team
investigated, collaborated with others, and adopted through proper
channels. Then, the Self Driven CEO, changes the system based on his own
agenda. I declined the postion because I am a dedicated systems person,
have been long before the 5th Discipline was published. I think there is
also, in the adherence to systems a thing called integrity - doing what we
say we will do. I could not help but be moved by the parents fighting the
good fight for their son. However, the Self Driven parent caused conflict
throughout the system. Some conflict is not legitimate, based solely on
ego and arenas of power. Some conflict keeps the tension so that the
system doesn't stagnate. Statistically speaking, I favor accepting the
system. Individually, I would fight the good fight for my kids, but that's
a matter of heart.
On the work floor and in the office I see so much of this Self Driven
experimentation, working outside the system. I refuse to give way to it
as it is similar to anarchy. I am being too stiff? Your point is well
taken as to the example. In law school I remember the old prof stating
that bad examples where often the stuff of changes in the law. I just
don't accept the Self Driven as I hold the system in too much respect -
statistically.
I would appreciate thoughts on the appropriateness of the Self Driven
challenging the system at every turn.
To the extent you intended, I agree it does show an interesting process
and thank you for suggesting it. I will turn next week to the MINDWALK
movie.
Tom Burke
Ramona, California
toburke@cts.com